Let's Talk Travel Podcast

Behind the Curtain Part 2: Follow the Money. Who's Actually Paying Your Travel Advisor, and What It Costs You

Two couples, same cruise, same cabin, same exact fare — but only one of them had someone in their corner for the next eleven months, and it didn’t cost them a dime. In this episode, host April Watson pulls back the curtain on the murkiest part of the travel advisor world: who pays whom, and why. She breaks down when using an advisor costs nothing, when it genuinely costs more (and what you’re actually buying when it does), and the honest reasoning behind the fees her own agency charges. From cruise commissions to custom land itineraries to what a network like Virtuoso really gets you, this is the straight answer to a question most people are too polite to ask — and one April thinks every traveler deserves to know.

Episode Transcript

[00:03] Imagine two couples on the same ship, same sailing, same category of cabin, same week at sea. They paid exactly the same fare. Not close, exactly the same. One of them booked it themselves on a Tuesday night after dinner. The other picked up the phone and had somebody do it for them. Now, inside that identical fare in both cases, there’s a commission. On one of those bookings, it went to a person whose job it was to be on their side for the next 11 months. On the other, the cruise line kept it. Nobody told the first couple that. Nobody tells most people that. So today, let’s follow the money. Welcome to Let’s Talk Travel. I’m April Watson of April Adventures Travel. This is part two of how travel planning actually works. Last time was what we actually do all day. The design, the hours, the reasons people hire us. Today is the part my industry, we’re vague about, which is what it costs you and who is paying whom.

[01:02] It’s a really murky area and it’s worth knowing how the industry works, so we’re going to pull back the curtain a little bit on this so you can understand some of the basics and why we do what we do. For most of what we book, we’re paid a commission by the supplier, the cruise line, the tour operator, the hotel, the resort, not by you. In most cases, it’s already built into the published price, which means if you book it yourself, the supplier simply keeps that portion. Now, my industry likes to say it never costs you more to use an advisor. That isn’t quite true. And you deserve the real answer. So just for simplicity’s sake, I’m gonna split it in three ways. Cruises. It costs you nothing, truly nothing. Cruise pricing is the same whether you book direct through us or through anyone else. The commission is already inside and built into the fair. Book it yourself and the cruise line just keeps their share.

[01:58] So on a cruise you’re choosing at identical cost between having somebody in your corner and not having one, I’d struggle to construct an argument for going in alone. Land travel. Yes, you’ll usually pay more. If we build you a custom itinerary in Ireland or Japan or Peru, we’re working through a specialist operator on the ground, private drivers, private guides, vetted properties, a local team who answers the phone when something goes sideways. That costs more than assembling it yourself from booking sites in a rental car. The same is true for researching and selecting a group tour. So some great examples of the kind of companies we’ll work with: Tauck, Micato, Abercrombie & Kent, African Travel. All this is going to cost you more, and that’s really because it’s seamless. It’s the private guides that they’ve known. It’s a structure that when you’re in it, when you’re going on a tour, you never have to worry about anything.

[02:54] And that has a price premium to it. So let’s be clear about what’s happening. You’re not paying a markup on the same product. You’re buying a different product. It isn’t the same trip at a higher price. It’s a different trip. It’s a driver who knows which road is closed, a guide who gets you through the gate before it’s open to the public. It’s a local office solving your problem in your time zone. And we’ve seen that more than once. And let me be clear as I can about what that means, because I’d much rather you heard it from me now than worked it out from a proposal later. When we design a complex itinerary or select a group tour, we’re not going item by item through the internet on your behalf and handing you the receipts. We’re building it with partners on the ground. Sometimes we call them DMCs, destination management companies. It’s a local operator, has their own team that helps us put together the itinerary to make it as smooth and wonderful as possible.

[03:52] That’s the thing that makes a complicated trip actually work. And it does set a floor under what it costs. Private, custom, and supported is a real category. And it’s not the least expensive way to see a place. But it is a very lovely, seamless, beautiful, memory-making way to do it. Hotels? It depends. And this is where people get confused, and it is confusing. So as agents, we have preferred partner programs with the major hotel brands. So that would be Marriott, Hilton, but there’s so many out there. The rate that we get is usually a hotel’s own best flexible rate. It’s the same number you’d find yourself, but the difference is with amenities added on top. Same price, more included. That’s the common case, and it’s genuinely a good deal. Not always. Sometimes, if you find a prepay or non-refundable rate, or you’re a high-tier loyalty member at the chain, you may find a lower number online than we can get ourselves.

[04:54] Then it’s a real trade. It’s cheaper with no flexibility and no extras, or slightly more with breakfast or credit and upgrade, and the right to change your mind. Sometimes the perks beat the difference, and sometimes they don’t. And we’ll tell you which plainly, rather than quietly booking the version that suits us better. Then let’s talk about a lot of agents do this and we do it as well, where we charge a fee and why we charge a fee. So there are three places where a commission doesn’t cover the work. And rather than be kind of coy about it, I’d rather explain the reasoning. The first is flights. Airlines essentially stopped paying travel advisors decades ago, maybe not that long ago, but long ago. Meanwhile, air is one of the most demanding things we handle. And if you heard our flight episodes, you know the list. Building the routing, protecting the conduction times. Heck, if you’ve flown, you’ve known the risks.

[05:49] You know the risks of flight travel. So watching the schedule change five or ten times, we charge a fee for air because it’s one of the most important parts of your trip. And it’s one that if it goes wrong, it can set the tone for the entire trip. So with just a few exceptions, we charge a fee for air, including business class. And here’s what I want you to take from that. The fee is a promise of attention. Flights are the one component where a small mistake isn’t small. A misconnection doesn’t cost you an hour. It costs you the first day of your trip. It can cost you getting on the ship on time. It’s the most fragile piece of any trip, and it’s the piece most people are tempted to handle themselves at late at night on a website they might not have used before. I’d rather tell you plainly that we charge for it than pretend otherwise and quietly give it less care than it deserves.

[06:43] It’s really important. So if we’re gonna handle it for you and we wanna make sure it is the best option available, then we charge a fee for it. The second is a planning fee on custom land trips. And here’s the logic: a custom land itinerary is built from nothing. There’s no catalog page to point at. Before a single thing is booked, somebody has to design the route, work out the pacing, all those details to produce a proposal. And all of that happens before you’ve decided anything at all, even if you’re going to go on that trip. The planning fee pays for the design, the time involved up front, which is the part that actually determines whether the trip is actually good. And the third is for all new clients. With a new client, there’s an additional piece of work that never repeats. That’s learning you, what you love, what you can’t stand, how you like to move, what’s comfortable means to you specifically.

[07:39] That first trip carries an investment, the fifth one doesn’t. And let me talk a little bit about what a network gets you. So here’s a piece of the industry nobody explains, and it’s where a small agency gets the leverage of a very large one. Above the day-to-day sits a consortium. Some of the most prominent are virtuoso, signature, ensemble, but there are others. These are buying groups. They’re actually marketing also groups, but they’re buying groups. There’s thousands of advisors pulling their business into collective volume and negotiating with the large hotel chains or the tour companies. And here’s what it gets you. At a participating virtuoso hotel, you typically receive daily breakfast for two, a room upgrade, early check-in, late checkout where possible, and a property credit or amenity. So you do the arithmetic on five nights, breakfast, all that, plus a better room. That’s frequently several hundred dollars of value on a booking that often costs exactly what the website was charging.

[08:38] So that’s what the buying power actually gets you, not a discount, but more in the box. Also, I’d like to talk a little bit about how we invest in our expertise and in your trips. So there’s one structural thing about this industry that most travelers don’t know, and it kind of explains a lot. Some travel advisors work for a large corporation, Amex Travel, AAA, the big branded agencies, often salaried or partly salaried, working inside that company’s systems and its preferred supplier list. It’s a perfectly legitimate model, and there are excellent people working in it and serving you. Others of us are independent, our own small businesses, affiliated with a host agency for the infrastructure, and a network like Virtuoso for the buying power. Independent advisors are paid entirely on commission, no salary underneath. And I mention it not for sympathy, but because of what it means for you. It means our livelihood rests on trip going well, well enough that you come back and that you tell your friends there’s no salary to fall back on if your holiday disappoints.

[09:42] Nobody’s hitting a monthly target by steering you toward the supplier of the month. That’s an alignment of interests that you should actively want in a person planning your trip. And there’s one more question worth asking, which is what somebody is a specialist in and how they earned it. Because some certifications you get by sitting through a course, others you earn by volume, meaning the network or the supplier has looked at how much business you actually placed in a category and certified you on that basis. So we happen to be virtuoso ultra luxury specialists, adventure travel, and cruise specialists. And both are earned by volume. That isn’t a class we attended. It’s a record of what we actually do day in and day out. So when anyone tells you they’re a specialist in something, ask how they got it. I took the course and I booked enough of these that the network certified me are very different answers.

[10:33] So that’s the money, for better or for worse. Some of the questions you may never ask laid out for you. On a cruise, an advisor costs you nothing at all. On hotels, it usually costs nothing. And sometimes it’s a genuine trade, and we’ll tell you plainly which. On land travel, you’ll likely pay more. And what you’re buying is a genuinely different trip, built with people on the ground that will be there to support you during that adventure. And where we charge a fee, it’s because the work is real and the commission doesn’t cover it. And what the fee buys is dedicated attention. Whoever you end up working with, we hope it’s us. But if it’s not, you are perfectly able to ask them how they’re paid. Not to catch anybody out, but because the answer tells you what they’re optimizing for and you’re entitled to know. A first conversation should always be free. You should come away from it knowing exactly how we’d approach your trip and exactly what it would cost.

[11:28] This is April Watson with Let’s Talk Travel. Until next time.